This is just an opinion, as they don’t violate the current terms of use of the marketplace, but, at JetBrains, do you have plans to prevent some developers to saturate the marketplace with an insane number of small plugins?
I can give names in private if you want. So, do you think it’s fair for a single developer (I did not say an AI , but, to be honest, it’s not humanly possible) to publish 192 plugins in two months? Honest developers lose all visibility. If you want to kill the marketplace, just let it turn into a rubbish tip. This is exactly what’s happening, and once the damage is done, it will be very difficult to rebuild a strong community.
The situation is terribly frustrating. We alerted you about the 15% commission, but it won’t be discussed before next year. We also alerted you about cases of large-scale plagiarism, but not much is happening (I know it’s complicated from a legal point of view, but there must be some sort of compromise), and now all this plugin spam.
I think there’s something worse than inaction, and that’s a lack of feedback (YouTrack issues have the same problem, but this is another story). And I know that many developers of high-quality and paid plugins are gradually finding themselves in a critical situation.
AI replaces plugins. It provides features originally only served by plugins. This is especially hard for language-support plugins, where AI does a great job. As a result, sales decrease.
AI makes it possible to create plugins more quickly. IMHO unless AI is used by a developer with JetBrains platform experience, the result is not good. The plugins I tested had very obvious bugs, had broken features and did not integrate at all into how the platform works, but they still claimed to be superior.
Neither is good for the Marketplace, in my opinion.
If both 1 and 2 continue or even accelerate, then I expect that some established vendors will leave the Marketplace. That means that users will lose well-made plugins and that JetBrains will lose the commission and a pull factor.
2 will accelerate unless there‘s a change to only accept well-made plugins. With a flood of barely working plugins (AI-made or not) users will look elsewhere for an IDE or just let AI do it and JetBrains‘ reputation takes a/another hit.
Yeah, the terms of use could be adapted to this new era. To give an example, Itch.io (a popular indie platform, similar to Steam) has just removed 10 TB of poor-quality AI-based games, and this is just the beginning.
Slop is legal, but the terms of use may well prohibit it, or at least restrict it
I think we all know who it is, it’s the Gap Software author, right? By checking into their website they absolutely automatized plugin submission. They are searching for “gaps” (hence the name), fix it and release it. It’s the whole “npm package that does one thing” all over again.
Thing is they don’t break any rules. Their plugins don’t use internal api, they are small enough to be thoroughly tested and it’s not like purely ai based plugins is forbidden. So yeah grit your teeth and complain like all of us with the advent of vibe coded technologies.
You’re right about visibility, but this ship has sailed ages ago. Since even before frontier AI was democratized the amount of low hanging fruit plugins had increased, and now between vibe coded plugins, reverse engineered ones and automatized, developers like yourselves who actually own the product are becoming obsolete.
The issue is really worldwide: I often see on X and Reddit how developers are becoming irrelevant and how everyone rushes to the market. There’s not much JB can do; in fact this One Piece era of development is profiting a lot to the marketplaces, they can benefit from a much quicker entry to market.
And what will you do? Leave the marketplace? And how are you going to attract users? Through X and Reddit? Good luck with that lol. If really you can pull this off then yeah I suppose you can leave the marketplace.
I think from JetBrains side, if you really want to help your long term developers, you should invest more on your “featured” sections. Analyze the project and provide recommendations to users.
Once we had Twitter and Blog posts featuring nice plugins. It’s not the case for a long time, so yeah I don’t think it will happen.
I was thinking about “readystack”, but he’s not alone.
I disagree. Some platforms accept slop, others explicitly reject it – such as Itchio – whilst others have not yet made a clear decision. JetBrains appears to be in this category, and I really hope it will take a stance, so that things will be clear and we can decide what to do.
Also, I don’t think X and Reddit reflect reality. What I see there are mainly desperate people and frightened newcomers, but many developers still have a job (it’s just changing a bit; they’re adapting). It’s all too easy to give up when the massive influx of slop is still a recent phenomenon. We can take action, and we’ll remember those who’ve taken a stand, and those who’ve chosen to either sacrifice or protect their community.
Slop does not breach marketplace rules, or even the law, but JetBrains’ marketplace rules could adapt and reject slop and/or flood. The marketplace has become impossible to navigate. And, as usual, the absence of response is the worst thing that can happen.
When I say vendors may “leave the Marketplace”, I mean they’ll stop developing and selling plugins.
If demand is dropping because of AI, and sales are falling because interested users can’t find the plugins anymore, then plugin development becomes unsustainable.
IMHO it’s up to JetBrains to steer things in the direction it wants. If that direction is a tenfold increase of plugins (working or not), then I think that outcome is inevitable.